Robinson Cole LLP
High Contrast Mode
Marquee

Property Insurance Coverage Litigation

Our Property Insurance Coverage Litigation practice group regularly handles some of the most complex property and business interruption insurance cases nationwide. We have been at the vanguard of almost every cutting-edge coverage battle fought in the past two decades.

We have substantial trial and appellate experience in cases involving all aspects of property insurance claims, including disputes under layered and quota-share excess programs, class actions, market conduct litigation, and other complex litigation. Members of our Insurance + Reinsurance practice group also regularly advise and represent insurer clients in appraisals and arbitrations arising from disputed claims. We are adept at assisting with fraud investigations, and advise clients with regard to coverage for pending claims.

Our Services

Our Property Insurance Coverage Litigation services include:  

  • Assisting with fraud investigations
  • Defense of complex litigation arising from property damage and business interruption losses
  • Counseling insurers on claim handling practices
  • Coverage advice
  • Representations in appraisals and arbitrations
  • Taking examinations under oath

Our team of property insurance has the depth and breadth of experience and knowledge required to address the unique issues and challenges of each case. We are adept at isolating the issues and developing the evidence in discovery that will support a dispositive motion. Where cases cannot be resolved at summary judgment, our team is ready and qualified to defend them through trial, and on appeal if necessary.

Because many lawsuits involving property insurance and business interruption claims also include allegations of bad faith and unfair insurance claims practices, we have extensive experience defending extra-contractual claims asserted against property insurers.

Our Team

Our Property Insurance Coverage Litigation team includes nationally recognized trial lawyers who have an unparalleled command of coverage law. Two of our partners are Fellows of the American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel. As a whole, our team of lawyers lead the field of property insurance law. We keep our clients alerted to developments in property insurance.

Many of our team members serve in leadership roles in national and international professional organizations related to property insurance, including the Insurance Law Committee of the American Bar Association’s Property Tort Trial and Insurance Practice Section (ABA-TIPS), and the Property Insurance Section of the Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel (FDCC).

We are also members of the International Association of Defense Counsel (IADC), and we serve as regular panelists at meetings of the Loss Executives Association (LEA), and the Property and Liability Research Bureau (PLRB). Several of our attorneys have developed and taught the course on Property Insurance Law which is taught as part of both the J.D. and the Insurance LL.M. programs at the University of Connecticut School of Law's Insurance Law Center.

Our top-tier Property Insurance Coverage Litigation team provides insurers with skilled legal services and unwavering representation on the most complex property and business interruption insurance cases nationwide. Our attorneys are committed to advancing your business objectives, while limiting your risk and exposure.

Experience


Insurance Coverage Litigation + Counseling: Mold + Other Contamination

Successfully represented a property insurer in a coverage and bad faith dispute involving claims for more than $30 million in damage for mold and other contamination of apartment complex. The case was tried before a federal court jury in Oklahoma City. After a week of trial, the case settled for considerably less than had been offered before trial commenced.

Read More

Insurance Coverage Litigation + Counseling: Hurricane Wilma Damage

Successfully defended a commercial property insurer in a Florida lawsuit seeking nearly $10 million in contract damages and attorneys' fees due to its alleged underpayment of a claim for Hurricane Wilma damage to an office tower. The dispute centered on whether posthurricane events involving the county building department triggered the policy's ordinance or law coverage and coverage for claimed rental value losses. Our defense of the case required a mastery of several Florida building codes, including the Florida Building Code, Existing Building, and the Florida Accessibility Code.

Read More

Boisse v. Miller

Boisse v. Miller, 267 A.3d 634 (R.I. 2022) – Affirming trial court judgment following bench trial (2013 WL 4235342 (R.I. Super. 2013)) in which court found for insurer defendant in direct action statute action and cross-claims that insurer had no liability under CGL policy because 1) claims involved pure economic injury, and thus claimants had not demonstrated they sustained property damage; 2) there was no occurrence because contractor’s work, while negligent, was not accidental; and 3) claimed loss resulted from the contractor’s negligent workmanship and was thus excluded by the express terms of the policy.

Read More


News


November 14, 2025

Robinson+Cole Secures Top Rankings in 2026 Edition of Best Law Firms®

Robinson+Cole has once again been recognized among the nation’s leading law firms, earning 46 first-tier metropolitan rankings and six national rankings in the 2026 edition of Best Law Firms®. These distinctions underscore the firm’s commitment to delivering exceptional client service and legal excellence across a broad range of practices and jurisdictions. Robinson+Cole six national rankings include: Tier 1 ranking for Land Use & Zoning Law; Tier 2 rankings for Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Commercial Litigation, Information Technology Law, and Real Estate Law; and Tier 3 ranking for Construction Law. Robinson+Cole achieved the following first-tier metropolitan rankings: Boston, MA – Tier 1 Information Technology Law Land Use & Zoning Law Real Estate Law Hartford, CT – Tier 1 Appellate Practice Banking and Finance Law Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law Commercial Litigation Construction Law Copyright Law Corporate Law Criminal Defense: White Collar Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law Employment Law – Management Energy Law Energy Regulatory Law Environmental Law Equipment Finance Law Health Care Law Insurance Law Labor Law - Management Land Use and Zoning Law Litigation - Bankruptcy Litigation - Construction Litigation - Environmental Litigation - Insurance Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions - Defendants Mergers & Acquisitions Law Public Finance Law Real Estate Law Securities/Capital Markets Law Trademark Law New York City, NY – Tier 1 Commercial Litigation Rhode Island – Tier 1 Commercial Litigation Energy Law Energy Regulatory Law Insurance Law Litigation - Insurance Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants Privacy and Data Security Law Real Estate Law Stamford, CT – Tier 1 Appellate Practice Insurance Law Litigation - Health Care Litigation - Insurance Litigation - Real Estate Real Estate Law Best Law Firms rankings are determined through a comprehensive, multi-layered evaluation process that incorporates client and professional references, firm-submitted data, lawyer evaluations, and leadership interviews. The 2026 research included input from over 18,700 firms, 27,000 lawyers, and more than 110,800 client submissions, resulting in 26 million evaluations and 16,401 client comments. Eligible firms must have at least one lawyer recognized in the current edition of The Best Lawyers in America® in the relevant practice area and jurisdiction. Rankings are grouped into tiers to reflect meaningful distinctions in performance rather than sequential order, ensuring a rigorous and transparent assessment of professional excellence. The full methodology can be found at https://www.bestlawfirms.com/methodology. 

Firm earns 6 national and 46 first-tier rankings in Boston, Hartford, New York, Rhode Island, and Stamford Markets
Robinson+Cole Secures Top Rankings in 2026 Edition of Best Law Firms® teaser
August 26, 2025

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2026

Firm receives top listing in Connecticut lawyer count in national peer review survey
78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2026 teaser
November 7, 2024

Robinson+Cole Receives 45 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in 2025 Edition of Best Law Firms®

Robinson+Cole Receives 45 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in 2025 Edition of <i>Best Law Firms</i>® teaser
November 14, 2025

Robinson+Cole Secures Top Rankings in 2026 Edition of Best Law Firms®

Robinson+Cole has once again been recognized among the nation’s leading law firms, earning 46 first-tier metropolitan rankings and six national rankings in the 2026 edition of Best Law Firms®. These distinctions underscore the firm’s commitment to delivering exceptional client service and legal excellence across a broad range of practices and jurisdictions. Robinson+Cole six national rankings include: Tier 1 ranking for Land Use & Zoning Law; Tier 2 rankings for Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Commercial Litigation, Information Technology Law, and Real Estate Law; and Tier 3 ranking for Construction Law. Robinson+Cole achieved the following first-tier metropolitan rankings: Boston, MA – Tier 1 Information Technology Law Land Use & Zoning Law Real Estate Law Hartford, CT – Tier 1 Appellate Practice Banking and Finance Law Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law Commercial Litigation Construction Law Copyright Law Corporate Law Criminal Defense: White Collar Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law Employment Law – Management Energy Law Energy Regulatory Law Environmental Law Equipment Finance Law Health Care Law Insurance Law Labor Law - Management Land Use and Zoning Law Litigation - Bankruptcy Litigation - Construction Litigation - Environmental Litigation - Insurance Mass Tort Litigation / Class Actions - Defendants Mergers & Acquisitions Law Public Finance Law Real Estate Law Securities/Capital Markets Law Trademark Law New York City, NY – Tier 1 Commercial Litigation Rhode Island – Tier 1 Commercial Litigation Energy Law Energy Regulatory Law Insurance Law Litigation - Insurance Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants Privacy and Data Security Law Real Estate Law Stamford, CT – Tier 1 Appellate Practice Insurance Law Litigation - Health Care Litigation - Insurance Litigation - Real Estate Real Estate Law Best Law Firms rankings are determined through a comprehensive, multi-layered evaluation process that incorporates client and professional references, firm-submitted data, lawyer evaluations, and leadership interviews. The 2026 research included input from over 18,700 firms, 27,000 lawyers, and more than 110,800 client submissions, resulting in 26 million evaluations and 16,401 client comments. Eligible firms must have at least one lawyer recognized in the current edition of The Best Lawyers in America® in the relevant practice area and jurisdiction. Rankings are grouped into tiers to reflect meaningful distinctions in performance rather than sequential order, ensuring a rigorous and transparent assessment of professional excellence. The full methodology can be found at https://www.bestlawfirms.com/methodology. 

Firm earns 6 national and 46 first-tier rankings in Boston, Hartford, New York, Rhode Island, and Stamford Markets
Robinson+Cole Secures Top Rankings in 2026 Edition of Best Law Firms® teaser
August 26, 2025

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2026

Firm receives top listing in Connecticut lawyer count in national peer review survey
78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2026 teaser
November 7, 2024

Robinson+Cole Receives 45 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in 2025 Edition of Best Law Firms®

Robinson+Cole Receives 45 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in 2025 Edition of <i>Best Law Firms</i>® teaser
October 31, 2024

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 Super Lawyers®

Thomson Reuters
Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
October 9, 2024

Robinson+Cole Recognized in 2025 Edition of Benchmark Litigation

August 15, 2024

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2025

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in <i>The Best Lawyers in America</i>© 2025 teaser
November 6, 2023

Robinson+Cole Receives 42 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in Latest Edition of Best Law Firms®

Best Law Firms
Robinson+Cole Receives 42 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in Latest Edition of Best Law Firms® teaser
October 26, 2023

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2023 Super Lawyers®

Super Lawyers
November 3, 2022

Robinson+Cole Receives 43 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Four National Rankings in Latest U.S. News – Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms”


October 31, 2024

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 Super Lawyers®

Thomson Reuters
Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
October 9, 2024

Robinson+Cole Recognized in 2025 Edition of Benchmark Litigation

August 15, 2024

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in The Best Lawyers in America© 2025

78 Robinson+Cole Lawyers Listed in <i>The Best Lawyers in America</i>© 2025 teaser
November 6, 2023

Robinson+Cole Receives 42 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in Latest Edition of Best Law Firms®

Best Law Firms
Robinson+Cole Receives 42 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Six National Rankings in Latest Edition of Best Law Firms® teaser
October 26, 2023

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2023 Super Lawyers®

Super Lawyers
November 3, 2022

Robinson+Cole Receives 43 First-Tier Metropolitan Rankings and Four National Rankings in Latest U.S. News – Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms”


Events


Past

Insurance Coverage and Investigative Considerations for Chinese Drywall Claims

January 2016
Loss Executives Association Annual Meeting
Past

Insurance Coverage and Investigative Considerations for Chinese Drywall Claims

January 2016
Loss Executives Association Annual Meeting