Robinson Cole LLP
High Contrast Mode

J. Tyler Butts represents the insurance industry in complex first-party property and third-party liability insurance coverage litigation throughout the country, with a focus on litigation concerning allegations of bad faith and other extra-contractual claims. He is part of our firm’s Litigation section and a member of our firm’s Insurance + Reinsurance group.

COVID-19 Pandemic

In the wake of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, Tyler has helped lead Robinson+Cole's efforts to advise, counsel, and defend our firm's insurance clients during these unprecedented times. He has been involved in COVID-19 related matters across the country, including in New York, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Texas, Arizona, and California, and has worked on litigation involving many different industries, including restaurants, entertainment venues, manufacturing risks, law firms, and personal service businesses. These claims have implicated numerous policy provisions, including those providing coverage for business interruption, extra expense, and civil authority, as well as policy exclusions for virus, ordinance & law, acts & decisions, and loss of use.

Property Insurance Coverage + Bad Faith Litigation

Tyler has extensive experience litigating and advising clients on complex property insurance coverage issues and allegations of bad faith and unfair claims settlement practices arising out of large property losses. He has been involved in property coverage disputes in a number of states, including Connecticut, New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Maryland, Virginia, Florida, Oklahoma, and Pennsylvania. He routinely litigates high-exposure claims arising from a wide variety of insurance lines, including commercial property, business interruption and extra expense, builder’s risk, boiler and machinery, liability, and high net-worth homeowners. Tyler is adept at working with expert witnesses in connection with property coverage disputes, including structural engineers, mechanical engineers, electrical engineers, cost estimators, appraisers, and forensic accountants.

Tyler has significant experience handling lawsuits asserting claims for extra-contractual damages, such as those available in Massachusetts under Chapter 93A and in Connecticut under the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act (CUTPA) and Connecticut Unfair Insurance Practices Act (CUIPA). He has successfully represented clients in arbitrations, appraisals, and other forms of alternative dispute resolution. He also has significant trial experience at both the state and federal level, having tried a number of cases to successful verdict, including recently recovering over $300,000 for his client after a jury trial determined that the insured homeowner had committed fraud when submitting her claim.

Write-Your-Own Insurance Carriers - National Flood Insurance Program

Tyler has considerable experience representing Write-Your-Own insurance carriers in litigation brought under the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s National Flood Insurance Program. He has litigated matters on behalf of WYO-carriers in a number of states, including New York, New Jersey, South Carolina, Oklahoma, and California. Tyler has successfully moved to dismiss WYO cases seeking bad faith or punitive damages, as well as suits that failed to comply with the Standard Flood Insurance Policy’s preconditions for initiating suit. He has also successfully resolved a number of litigated matters prior to incurring significant fees in discovery and motion practice.

Pro Bono

Tyler is committed to pro bono work. He participates in our firm’s Domestic Violence Restraining Order Program, and provides free legal services to family violence victims, including helping them obtain restraining orders and navigate the family court system. He also provides pro bono services to incarcerated individuals asserting violations of their civil rights under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Because of his efforts, Tyler was Robinson+Cole’s Pro Bono Service Award Recipient in 2013.

Prior to joining Robinson+Cole, Tyler worked with a national law firm on securities and probate litigation as well as on complex class action matters.

  • The College of William & Mary School of Law (Juris Doctor, Order of the Coif)
    • Notes Editor of the William & Mary Law Review
  • The College of William & Mary (Bachelors, magna cum laude)
    • B.A., History and Government
    • Monroe Scholar

  • State of Connecticut
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, 3rd Circuit
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, 9th Circuit
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, 10th Circuit
  • U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut
  • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
  • U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York

Robinson+Cole Mentor of the Year Award recipient, 2019

Robinson+Cole Pro Bono Service Award recipient, 2013 and 2018

Selected as a Rising Star to the Connecticut Super Lawyers list from 2013 to 2020

Connecticut Coalition Against Domestic Violence, "First 100," 2013

Connecticut Bar Association Young Lawyers Section Leadership Award recipient, 2022

American Bar Association

Connecticut Bar Association
Young Lawyers Section, Executive Committee, Membership Director
Insurance Law Section, Treasurer (2020 - 2022)
Insurance Law Section, Secretary (2022 - 2023)

Connecticut Bar Foundation
James W. Cooper Fellow

Civics First
Board of Directors

United Way
Co-Chair of R&C's United Way Drive (2020)

Experience


Commercial Business Litigation: Action Against Energy Services Corporation Dismissed

Successfully dismissed Connecticut state court action against directors of an energy services corporation based on plaintiff shareholders’ failure to bring suit as a derivative action in a matter arising from the $25 million sale of the corporation’s assets.

Read More

Commercial Business Litigation: Trademark Infringing Merchandise Sale

Represented technology services firm in connection with action brought by global design house concerning alleged complicity in the sale of trademark-infringing merchandise.

Property Insurance Litigation: Hurricane Irene Losses

Represented a commercial property insurer in a federal New York lawsuit arising from the denial of eight separate claims across five of the insured’s supermarkets in New York and Pennsylvania. The claims, which involved losses allegedly caused by Hurricane Irene, power interruption, and copper thefts, were denied on the grounds that the damages claimed were fraudulently inflated and exacerbated by the actions of the insured. On the eve of trial, we were able to resolve the case through settlement on terms that were extremely favorable to our client.

Read More


Publications


February 2022

"Pre-Litigation Review” and “Removal”

Property Insurance Litigator’s Handbook, Third Edition (2022)

Edited by Andrew B. Downs, Jay M. Levin and Heidi Hudson Raschke (2022), published by the American Bar Association.

Legal Update: New York State Paid Sick Leave Takes Effect; New York City Amends Local Law to Conform, Impose Additional Requirements teaser
October 2, 2020

Legal Update: New York State Paid Sick Leave Takes Effect; New York City Amends Local Law to Conform, Impose Additional Requirements

Legal Update: EEOC Releases Updates to COVID-19 Technical Assistance Questions and Answers (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
September 25, 2020

Legal Update: EEOC Releases Updates to COVID-19 Technical Assistance Questions and Answers (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

February 2022

"Pre-Litigation Review” and “Removal”

Property Insurance Litigator’s Handbook, Third Edition (2022)

Edited by Andrew B. Downs, Jay M. Levin and Heidi Hudson Raschke (2022), published by the American Bar Association.

Legal Update: New York State Paid Sick Leave Takes Effect; New York City Amends Local Law to Conform, Impose Additional Requirements teaser
October 2, 2020

Legal Update: New York State Paid Sick Leave Takes Effect; New York City Amends Local Law to Conform, Impose Additional Requirements

Legal Update: EEOC Releases Updates to COVID-19 Technical Assistance Questions and Answers (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
September 25, 2020

Legal Update: EEOC Releases Updates to COVID-19 Technical Assistance Questions and Answers (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Federal District Court Expands Employee Paid Leave Rights Under FFCRA (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
August 19, 2020

Legal Update: Federal District Court Expands Employee Paid Leave Rights Under FFCRA (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
April 2, 2020

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: EPA Issues COVID-19 Enforcement Discretion Policy teaser
March 31, 2020

Legal Update: EPA Issues COVID-19 Enforcement Discretion Policy

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 31, 2020

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Employers Take Note of the CARES Act: More Paid Sick And Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 27, 2020

Legal Update: Employers Take Note of the CARES Act: More Paid Sick And Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Need to Reduce Staff? Consider Shared Work Programs to Lessen the Pain (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 26, 2020

Legal Update: Need to Reduce Staff? Consider Shared Work Programs to Lessen the Pain (COVID-19 Coronavirus)



Legal Update: Federal District Court Expands Employee Paid Leave Rights Under FFCRA (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
August 19, 2020

Legal Update: Federal District Court Expands Employee Paid Leave Rights Under FFCRA (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
April 2, 2020

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: EPA Issues COVID-19 Enforcement Discretion Policy teaser
March 31, 2020

Legal Update: EPA Issues COVID-19 Enforcement Discretion Policy

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 31, 2020

Legal Update: Paid Sick and Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Employers Take Note of the CARES Act: More Paid Sick And Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 27, 2020

Legal Update: Employers Take Note of the CARES Act: More Paid Sick And Family Leave Legislation in Response to Coronavirus (COVID-19 Coronavirus)

Legal Update: Need to Reduce Staff? Consider Shared Work Programs to Lessen the Pain (COVID-19 Coronavirus) teaser
March 26, 2020

Legal Update: Need to Reduce Staff? Consider Shared Work Programs to Lessen the Pain (COVID-19 Coronavirus)


News


November 29, 2023

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Named to the Connecticut District Court’s 2023 Pro Bono Honor Roll

Hartford lawyers J. Tyler Butts, Jason DePatie, Edward Heath, and Rachel Kushel were among the lawyers named to the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut's 2023 Pro Bono Honor Roll. The recognition highlights their accepted appointments and devotion in rendering pro bono legal services to unrepresented litigants in civil cases in the state of Connecticut who could otherwise not afford it. View the Pro Bono Honor Roll.

February 10, 2023

J. Tyler Butts and John Cordani Selected as James W. Cooper Fellows of the Connecticut Bar Foundation

Law360
September 19, 2022

J. Tyler Butts Is Honored at CBA Young Lawyers Section Annual Retreat

November 29, 2023

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Named to the Connecticut District Court’s 2023 Pro Bono Honor Roll

Hartford lawyers J. Tyler Butts, Jason DePatie, Edward Heath, and Rachel Kushel were among the lawyers named to the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut's 2023 Pro Bono Honor Roll. The recognition highlights their accepted appointments and devotion in rendering pro bono legal services to unrepresented litigants in civil cases in the state of Connecticut who could otherwise not afford it. View the Pro Bono Honor Roll.

February 10, 2023

J. Tyler Butts and John Cordani Selected as James W. Cooper Fellows of the Connecticut Bar Foundation

Law360
September 19, 2022

J. Tyler Butts Is Honored at CBA Young Lawyers Section Annual Retreat

November 18, 2020

Robinson+Cole Elects New Partners and Counsel

October 14, 2020

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized by Super Lawyers®

Super Lawyers
August 26, 2020

J. Tyler Butts Elected Treasurer of Connecticut Bar Assoc. Insurance Law Section

October 17, 2019

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized by Super Lawyers®

April 11, 2019

J. Tyler Butts and Ray DeMeo Take Part in ALI’s Restatement of Law Liability Insurance Conference

March 20, 2019

Tyler Butts Co-Presents National Webinar on Handling Difficult Contractors


November 18, 2020

Robinson+Cole Elects New Partners and Counsel

October 14, 2020

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized by Super Lawyers®

Super Lawyers
August 26, 2020

J. Tyler Butts Elected Treasurer of Connecticut Bar Assoc. Insurance Law Section

October 17, 2019

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized by Super Lawyers®

April 11, 2019

J. Tyler Butts and Ray DeMeo Take Part in ALI’s Restatement of Law Liability Insurance Conference

March 20, 2019

Tyler Butts Co-Presents National Webinar on Handling Difficult Contractors


Events


Past

Complex Coverage Issues in Cyber Claims

Mar 31 2025
PLRB 2025 Claims Conference
Past

Cyber Coverage & Claims: Recent Trends

March 19 and 20, 2024
Property & Liability Resource Bureau Claims Conference & Insurance Services Expo
Past

Complex Coverage Issues in Cyber Claims

Mar 31 2025
PLRB 2025 Claims Conference
Past

Cyber Coverage & Claims: Recent Trends

March 19 and 20, 2024
Property & Liability Resource Bureau Claims Conference & Insurance Services Expo
Past

COVID-19: At the Intersection of Property Insurance and Science

Apr 6 2020
R+C Webinar
Past

The World Turned Upside Down

Apr 5 2019
American Law Institute’s Restatement of Law Liability Insurance conference
Past

Dealing With Difficult Contractors

Mar 14 2019
Property and Liability Resource Bureau
Past

Connecticut Insurance 2018 Year-in-Review

Feb 5 2019
Connecticut Bar Association Insurance Law Section
Past

COVID-19: At the Intersection of Property Insurance and Science

Apr 6 2020
R+C Webinar
Past

The World Turned Upside Down

Apr 5 2019
American Law Institute’s Restatement of Law Liability Insurance conference
Past

Dealing With Difficult Contractors

Mar 14 2019
Property and Liability Resource Bureau
Past

Connecticut Insurance 2018 Year-in-Review

Feb 5 2019
Connecticut Bar Association Insurance Law Section