Robinson Cole LLP
High Contrast Mode

Rita E. Nerney represents clients in commercial litigation matters, primarily in managed care and insurance disputes. She also has experience representing clients in a wide range of complex business and commercial litigation, employment matters, energy-related matters, internal and government investigations. In addition, Rita has represented educational institutions, addressing various investigative matters, including Title IX issues and governance concerns. She has also worked on matters involving insurance coverage, professional liability, and general liability issues.

Prior to entering private practice, Rita law clerked for the Honorable Gilbert V. Indeglia, as Associate Justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court. She has also clerked for the Rhode Island Trial Court Law Clerk Department. During law school, Rita served as a Judicial Extern for the Honorable O. Rogeriee Thompson of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit.

  • Roger Williams University School of Law (Juris Doctor, summa cum laude)
    • Roger Williams University Law Review, Articles Editor
    • Roger Williams University School of Law Pro Bono Collaborative, Law Student Partner
    • 2016 Pro Bono Collaborative Award Recipient
  • Rhode Island College (Bachelors, cum laude)
    • B.A., English
    • Dean's List

  • Commonwealth of Massachusetts
  • State of Connecticut
  • State of New York
  • State of Rhode Island
  • U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut
  • U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts
  • U.S. District Court, District of Rhode Island
  • U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit
  • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
  • U.S. District Court, District of Columbia

Recognized as a 2024 Up & Coming Lawyer by Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly

Selected as a Rising Star to the Massachusetts Super Lawyers list for 2024 and 2025

Selected by her peers for inclusion in Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in the area of Commercial Litigation for 2023

Recognized in Rhode Island Monthly’s Professional Excellence in Law awards from 2019 to 2020

Rocky Hill Country Day School
Board of Directors (2023 - present)

Rhode Island Women's Bar Association
Member (2016 - present)

Century Drywall ESOP
Board of Directors (2020 - present)

Nurses Middle College Network of Schools
Board of Directors (2021 - present)

Girls on the Run Rhode Island
Board of Directors (2019 - 2022)
Board Chair (2021 - 2022)
Vice Chair (2020 - 2021)

Leadership Rhode Island
Member of Rho II Class (2021)

Roger Williams University School of Law
Alumni Association Board of Directors (2018 - 2021)

Experience


Successful Defense of Medicaid Managed Care Plan in Provider Reimbursement Arbitration

Represented a Medicaid managed care organization in an AHLA arbitration brought by a behavioral health provider alleging years of systemic underpayment. The arbitrator dismissed all claims in their entirety based on failure to exhaust contractual remedies and lack of entitlement to higher reimbursement rates, eliminating more than $1.5 million in claimed exposure.

Read More

Lead Trial Counsel in Six-Day Arbitration

Successfully defended arbitration commenced by in-network hospital seeking $73,000,000 on 50,000-plus claims. Served as lead trial counsel in six-day arbitration involving expert topics such as medical necessity, sampling methodology, statistical analysis, medical claim coding, and revenue cycle management. Hearing resulted in a highly favorable award, allowing significantly less than 1% of original claim.

Read More

News


April 7, 2026

Ray Carta and Rita Nerney Discuss Current No Surprises Act Litigation

Managed Care + ERISA Litigation group members Raymond J. Carta and Rita E. Nerney informed readers that the “extensive litigation between out-of-network providers and insurers” rages on in their article, “The Current State of the No Surprises Act Litigation,” published in DRI’s For The Defense March 2026 issue. They point out that “…federal courts have coalesced around the determination that the NSA does not permit lawsuits by out-of-network providers to confirm MSA awards from the IDR  [independent dispute resolution] process…” and that the “current administration has promised new agency guidance to streamline the IDR process in early 2026.” Read the article.

For The Defense
January 5, 2026

Robinson+Cole Promotes New Partners and Counsel in Strategic Practices and Markets

Firm names three partners and eight counsel in New York, Boston, Hartford, Providence, and Stamford
November 6, 2025

Robinson+Cole Commends 62 Attorneys Recognized in 2025 Super Lawyers®

Recognition spans key regions and highlights the firm’s seasoned practitioners and emerging leaders in many business transactions and litigation practices
Robinson+Cole Commends 62 Attorneys Recognized in 2025 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
April 7, 2026

Ray Carta and Rita Nerney Discuss Current No Surprises Act Litigation

Managed Care + ERISA Litigation group members Raymond J. Carta and Rita E. Nerney informed readers that the “extensive litigation between out-of-network providers and insurers” rages on in their article, “The Current State of the No Surprises Act Litigation,” published in DRI’s For The Defense March 2026 issue. They point out that “…federal courts have coalesced around the determination that the NSA does not permit lawsuits by out-of-network providers to confirm MSA awards from the IDR  [independent dispute resolution] process…” and that the “current administration has promised new agency guidance to streamline the IDR process in early 2026.” Read the article.

For The Defense
January 5, 2026

Robinson+Cole Promotes New Partners and Counsel in Strategic Practices and Markets

Firm names three partners and eight counsel in New York, Boston, Hartford, Providence, and Stamford
November 6, 2025

Robinson+Cole Commends 62 Attorneys Recognized in 2025 Super Lawyers®

Recognition spans key regions and highlights the firm’s seasoned practitioners and emerging leaders in many business transactions and litigation practices
Robinson+Cole Commends 62 Attorneys Recognized in 2025 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
October 31, 2024

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 Super Lawyers®

Thomson Reuters
Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
June 5, 2024

George Watson and Rita Nerney Recognized at Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly’s 2024 Excellence Awards

Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly
George Watson and Rita Nerney Recognized at <i>Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly</i>’s 2024 Excellence Awards teaser

October 31, 2024

Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 Super Lawyers®

Thomson Reuters
Robinson+Cole Lawyers Recognized in 2024 <i>Super Lawyers</i>® teaser
June 5, 2024

George Watson and Rita Nerney Recognized at Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly’s 2024 Excellence Awards

Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly
George Watson and Rita Nerney Recognized at <i>Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly</i>’s 2024 Excellence Awards teaser

Events


Past

The No Surprises Act: More Surprises, Even More Litigation

Apr 29 2026
DRI 2026 Life, Health, Disability and ERISA Seminar
Past

Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly 2024 Excellence in the Law Awards

Jun 4 2024
Crowne Plaza Providence-Warwick
Past

The No Surprises Act: More Surprises, Even More Litigation

Apr 29 2026
DRI 2026 Life, Health, Disability and ERISA Seminar
Past

Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly 2024 Excellence in the Law Awards

Jun 4 2024
Crowne Plaza Providence-Warwick